Change Up-----Maybe

Of course I've been out shopping and checking out a new store,
B and B Home Shop--The Vintage Marketplace at Glenwood, and of course I found a chair to purchase.  I know, the last thing I needed was another chair.  But, it was black and it was patent leather, and I loved it.

Now, here's the change up----maybe.   You know that I just buy because I like it and think about where I'll put it later.  I thought it would be a good desk chair next to my spinet desk.
(If you missed the post about the desk, go here.)

New Chair Next to Desk

Now, here's the quandary.   I already have this lovely chinoiserie chair that I covered with my favorite gray zebra fabric.

Original Desk Chair

I like them both.  I love the black they both have.  The new chair has gold trim that works perfectly in the room.  The chinoiserie chair works better style wise since I have a chinoiserie chandelier on the other side of the desk.

Help!!!!! I need input to decide.  What should I do?
 (Please don't say stop shopping.)

Let me know what you think.

Kathy